It comes as no secret to my PLN Twitter friends…I am tremendously disappointed by Fliggo’s decision to roll Fliggo into Vidly. As an educator, I heartily supported Fliggo, but I cannot recommend Vidly. Since learning of Fliggo’s decision, I have been reviewing and exploring and searching for a replacement site. So far, the closest I have come to finding a student-safe place where students and children can view YouTube videos is Totlol. I offer my recommendation for Totlol with some reservations.
First, these are the things I liked about Totlol….
- Totlol is powered by the YouTube API. I do not feel comfortable opening YouTube to our student population, but gosh darned there are some great videos for learning and motivation posted on YouTube!
- Totlol allows the user (most likely a parent, possibly a teacher) to optimize an account based on the age group of children: toddler, preschool, kindergarten, young kids, and tweens. Totlol’s Age-Optimized Interfaces enable kids of different ages to interact with the site and the video content in different ways. (click here to link to an excellent visual comparison of the interfaces).
- When using Totlol as a logged-in adult (with a paid account) you have access to personalization features, you can participate in the community by submitting and screening videos, and you will be able to play and create video collections.
- As a paid member, you can also link your YouTube account and activate or deactivate a parent lock. This means that children can view a YouTube on this site, but will not be able to click on the YouTube link embedded in each video.
- While I do not feel young children should be given free rein of the Internet, it can be difficult to constantly monitor your child while he/she is on the Internet (phone calls, interruptions, etc.). A parent or teacher could be fairly confident that a child could not link to the YouTube site and the public content available on Totlol is monitored and approved by a community of parents.
- The creator of this site was very responsive and helpful when I corresponded with him. Please take time to read our email correspondence found at the end of this post.
While there are few things that I could find that I did not like about Totlol in terms of navigation and management I do wish…
- I did not have to pay for an account so that I could review and work with the site. The fee was minimal, but I do not have to filter content in my household since my children are adults. Basically, I had to pay for an account in order to review this product for my blog.
- this niftly little site could be used in a school environment. Unfortunately, if YouTube is blocked in your school the videos that are available in Totlol will also be blocked since videos are delivered directly from YouTube (blocking the YouTube domain blocks Totlol).
- personal videos could be uploaded from your home computer. As it stands now…home (or school) videos must be loaded to YouTube first (which means that content will likely be blocked in a school environment).
I had high hopes that I had finally struck upon a site that could replace Fliggo. While, there is no doubt that this application serves as a wonderful interface for young children viewing videos from a home computer, I don’t think it will work in a school environment at this time. Parents, check out this marvelous service. Teachers, I will continue to search for a Fliggo replacement. Please read over the email exchange I had with Ron, the gifted creator of this site.
This was my email to Ron…
I recently came across your site and am very impressed with the ability to lock the site so students/children cannot link to YouTube. Have you considered working with schools to offer solutions for teachers/administrators so they could also lock an account of teacher sanctioned YouTube videos on a larger scope?
By the way, I will be reviewing your product on my edtech blog at http://farroutlinks.net/blog sometime in the next day or so. (I do kind of wish I had not had to pay to try the service by the way).
Thank you for your consideration,
Jen
This was Ron’s quick and helpful reply to my email…
Hi Jen,
Thanks for the mail. I’ll try and and answer as best I can, though some things are complex than they seem…
1. I see Totlol as an enabler not a disabler and designed it this way. Having lots of easily accessible, great stuff is the best way to keep people from going elsewhere…. The Parent Lock is meant to prevent accidental clicks and outside distractions. While it is effective, it does not block the ability of the browser/network to access other sites.
2. In regard to schools:
a. I have received several requests along the lines you suggest – which basically boils down to having a “teacher-level” account functionality that can guide and direct associated student accounts. I have a pretty good idea how to actually implement this – but to be bluntly honest – I don’t see this happening without it being a funded project, and I don’t see a funded project happening any time soon.
b. A lot of schools block the domain youtube.com at the network level. Since videos are delivered directly from YouTube, blocking the domain blocks Totlol. There is a technical solution for this, but it requires, for youtube to make some technical changes to the way the API system is set up. I have seen no sign that it will happen.
3. I built Totlol by myself and have to abide to a very rigid framework of terms set by YouTube. Membership fees were suggested by users as an alternative to closing the site and after careful consideration this is the route I chose to follow.
The site contains no advertising, sponsorship or promotions of any kind and it supported solely by it’s members.
If you have any other questions – feel free to ask.
Best,
Ron
If you are looking for strategies to share YouTube videos in a classroom environment you might also want to check out my School-Friendly Video Saving and Sharing Strategies post….keep in my Fliggo is no longer an option.






